This treat has it all!
- 3 ingredients (including a surprising one you are likely to have on hand right now!)
- Very easy
- No special equipment - all you need is a microwave!
- Fast
- Delicious - Obviously. It tastes like a Butterfinger!
- Inexpensive
- * Well, it isn't healthy, but it's candy after all! *
Homemade Butterfinger Candy
Makes ~24 bars (one 9x13 pan)
1 lb candy corn
1 16 oz. jar peanut butter
16 oz. package chocolate candy coating*
Place peanut butter in a medium bowl. In a separate bowl that is microwaveable, melt candy corn in microwave 1 minute; stir. Continue cooking for 15 seconds at a time, stirring in between, until melted. Pour candy corn liquid into peanut butter bowl and stir together; make sure to work quickly as the mixture will harden in just a few minutes. Spread peanut butter mixture in a greased 9x13 pan. Let cool completely; you can even do this step 1-2 days ahead as the bottom layer becomes crunchier/more like the candy with time.
Melt chocolate coating in microwave and pour over peanut butter layer. Cool until coating is set, cut into squares, and enjoy!
I prefer to store this in the refrigerator as the texture is a bit more crisp, but you don't need to.
* Note, you could definitely substitute part of the candy coating for semi-sweet or other chocolate chips for a more gourmet version, but this tastes just like the candy we all know and love.